Article

Who or what is actually being tested in the book of Job?

October 21, 2020 - drs. G. (Gijs) van den Brink
Part 2 of 7 of the theme 'Lessons from the Bible book of Job' by Gijs van den Brink

 

Most sermons and literature on the book of Job argue that Job's suffering should be seen as a trial, as a test. But what is actually the major theme of the book of Job? Who or what is being tested here? Is that 1. Job suffering innocently? Or is that
2. the retributive principle, that God punishes sin and rewards justice? Or is it
3. Is God fair and just in His judgment and direction of Job's life? Is God just in the way He deals with people? 

The theme in the book of Job can be imagined as a triangle with three subjects, which are in constant play:
1. The just government of God, 2. The justice and goodness of Job, and 3. The retributive principle. Those who are righteous are rewarded; those who sin are punished.

The retaliatory principle

Job's friends defend the retributive principle. That is, some form of it. The Bible certainly teaches divine retribution. The righteous is blessed, the sinner receives misfortune and suffering (e.g., in Psalm 1).
But Job's friends draw the wrong conclusion from this. They reverse the Biblical principle and say: he who experiences prosperity is a righteous one, and he who suffers or is sick in a special way has sinned. 

The friends Elifaz, Bildad and Sofar all three defend the retributive principle, but the reasons they give differ. Elifaz is a mystic and spiritualist and speaks from his own spiritual experiences (4:8, 12-16; 5:3). Bildad is a traditionalist (8:8), who relies mainly on what has been handed down to him, what he has been told. Sofar is a rationalist, arguing from reason and logic.

But more importantly, all three of them are accomplices of the accuser, of Satan! If Job were to act on their ideas, then Satan would be proved right in his accusation. Then it would be shown that God's way of dealing with man would be wrong, as Satan claimed. Satan argued that Job lives righteously only because he is materially blessed (1:9-10).


Next time: Is God righteous or Job?

See also: Part 1 of 7 of the theme 'Lessons from the Bible book of Job' Battle between God and Satan

Author: Gijs van den Brink
From: Study Bible Magazine


This is part 2 of 7 concise blog on the topic "Lessons from the Bible Book of Job" from Study Bible Magazine, Some of which we will be posting online in the near future. We hope this will help you understand the Bible better!

 


Download the Study Bible App for FREE at Play Store or  App StoreEnter this login code (BLOGCVB2020) in order to have 45 days of FREE access to the Study Bible Solomon package (the most comprehensive package).

Contribution of

drs. G. (Gijs) van den Brink
Since 1981 working as editor and author on a commentary series known as "Study Bible." First at IDR in Soest, from 1998 at the "Center for Bible Research" (CVB) in Doorn. From 1996 to 2015 editor NT of the quarterly magazine for evangelical theological reflection "Soteria". Since 2007 editor-in-chief of the quarterly theological journal "Study Bible magazine". From 2010-2011 editorial board member of Tussenruimte, journal for intercultural theology.

Stay inspired!

Do you always want to stay up to date with interesting Study Bible news, inspiring content and exclusive offers? Then sign up for our newsletter now!
Newsletter Sign Up
Twee vormen van discipelschap in de Evangeliën
2 March 2026

Er wordt in de evangeliën onderscheid gemaakt tussen de twaalf discipelen en een ruimere kring van volgelingen die niet met Jezus meereizen. Dit lijkt een vanzelfsprekendheid, maar de vraag die direct opkomt, is wel wat dan het verschil is tussen de twaalf en de andere volgelingen. Is dat verschil in het evangelie ook aanwijsbaar, bijvoorbeeld…

Read more
Herziene Bijbelse tijdlijn
23 February 2026

Vergelijkende chronologie van Assyrië en Israël De gangbare chronologie van de IJzertijd II, waarin Israël en Juda opkwamen, steunt op drie Assyrische ankerpunten, die bij nadere beschouwing niet kloppen. Die chronologie heeft geleid tot een domino-effect van verschoven regeringen, kunstmatige co-regentschappen en botsingen met Bijbelse, Assyrische en archeologische gegevens, waardoor bij onderzoekers het vertrouwen in…

Read more
Is it possible for a Christian to lose his preservation?
26 January 2026

Kan een christen zijn behoud verliezen? Het eenvoudige antwoord hierop is wat Paulus zegt in Rom.10:9 ‘Als uw mond belijdt dat Jezus de Heer is en uw hart gelooft dat God hem uit de dood heeft opgewekt, zult u worden gered’.Want Jezus heeft onze zonden aan het kruis voor ons gedragen. Hij stierf in mijn…

Read more