Article, Contradictions in the Bible!?

Opposition in the Bible!? 5: Census by David of God or of Satan?

February 29, 2024 - drs. G. (Gijs) van den Brink


Is the census by David in the book of 2Samuel and 1Chronicles described contradictorily? 

2 Sam. 24:1 'Again the Lord kindled wrath against Israel. He set David against the people, saying, 'Go and take a census in Israel and Judah.'

1 Chron. 21:1 "Satan turned against Israel and prompted David to take a census in Israel.

Sometimes God takes initiative, other times Satan. A contradiction? First, one can understand the Hebrew satan in 1 Chronicles also translate with "adversary," which is often the correct translation in the OT. In that case, this would refer to a foreign enemy pressuring David to take a census. And in 2 Samuel Is it possible to translate, "Again the Lord kindled wrath against Israel. Someone pitted David against the people ...

But then still remains here that in 2 Samuel God takes the initiative and in 1 Chronicles Satan or a human enemy. But two authors (God and Satan) of the same event are very common in a spiritual sense. Satan executes what God allows. We see this also in the NT, for example in Jesus' temptation in the desert: 'Then Jesus was by the Spirit Led to the desert to be tempted by the devil (Mat.4:1).
And Paul says in 2 Cor. 12:7, "To prevent me from exalting myself, I was (by God) a thorn in the flesh: I am tormented by a angel of Satan.'

Both also involve one event that can be viewed from two perspectives. 

2 Samuel described the event from God's perspective and 1 Chronicles from the power of sin and the punishment that follows, which is a recurring perspective in Chronicles.

The perspective of two authors may differ.

Contribution of

drs. G. (Gijs) van den Brink
Since 1981 working as editor and author on a commentary series known as "Study Bible." First at IDR in Soest, from 1998 at the "Center for Bible Research" (CVB) in Doorn. From 1996 to 2015 editor NT of the quarterly magazine for evangelical theological reflection "Soteria". Since 2007 editor-in-chief of the quarterly theological journal "Study Bible magazine". From 2010-2011 editorial board member of Tussenruimte, journal for intercultural theology.

Stay inspired!

Do you always want to stay up to date with interesting Study Bible news, inspiring content and exclusive offers? Then sign up for our newsletter now!
Newsletter Sign Up